Tuesday, 10 November 2015

CODE OF CONDUCT TRIBUNAL AND THE INHERENT CONTRADICTIONS IN THE NIGERIAN LEGAL SYSTEM

CODE OF CONDUCT TRIBUNAL AND THE INHERENT CONTRADICTIONS IN THE NIGERIAN LEGAL SYSTEM BY F.O AMEDU ESQ.

The Nigerian Legal System rest securely upon the twin pillars of " Audi alterem patem" & Nemo judex in Causa which if translated from Latin simply means "Hear the other side" and "No man should be a judge in his own court" respectively. Although a colonial heritage our forebears accepted the principle to preserve the santity of our system of abjudication and to prevent a system of judicial tyranny where by an indivual or institution is invested with all the powers to investigate, prosecute and judge all at the same time, as it has been accepted as true, that absolute power corrupts absolutely, hence the need to put in place systems that will checkmate and ensure balance in the adminstration of justice.
In keeping with the above, the constitution empowers certain agencies to prosecute on the one hand e.g the police is vested with the powers to investigate and prosecute indivuals where it is alleged that they have commited a crime, however the power to abjudicate is vested in the courts of law, which is the only arm of governmented invested with the vires to reach a conclusion as to the guilt of a defendant or accused person. As the case may be in the light of the evidence produced by the prosecution in proof of their case. Similarly while the Economic and Fiancial Crimes Commision is empowered to investigate and Prosecute indivuals ( natural or artificial) who are alleged to have commited finincial crimes, however the law provides for the commision to promptly charge such indivuals to court,the same holds for specialised agencies like NAPTIP,NDLEA etc.
It becomes extremely strange therefore to find that an institution as strategic and powerful as the Code of Conduct Bureau and the Code of Conduct Tribunal, both sister agencies will be given the wide and all encompassing powers of investigating, Prosecuting and abjudicating on cases involving indivuals alleged to have breached the code of conduct for public officers.
Public office is a position of trust and indivuals elected or appointed owe the citzens on whose behalf they act the duty of being honesty and fair in their dealings and not to use their office to Promote their personal interest, hence the code of conduct Bureau and the Code of Conduct tribunal was first established by the 1979 Constitution to enforce the code of conduct for public Officers. It is presently contained in the Third schedule
Part 1 , Section A, while the code of conduct for public officers is contained in the fifth schedule. The CCB & the CCT being the first specialised agency established to fight and curtail corruption in public office is invested with very unique responsiblities which includes but not limited to adminstering the assets declaration form ( CCB- 1) conducting enlightment campaigns for public office holders and monitoring the assets declared by public officers to ascertain whether they have acquired wealth beyond their ordinary and legitmate source of income.
Since inception in 1989 Nigerians have not really felt the real impact of the organisation, apart from a few pockets of cases that pops up at the tribunal occasionally prominent among which includes the trial of former Lagos state Governor and APC strongman and the recent trial of Senate President, Bukola Saraki all cases which are generally perceived as politically motivated trials aimed at checkmating the influence of political rivals by the powers that be. It is worthy of note that since its inception over twenty years ago and with an annual budget of 8.3 million dollars, the commision has not secured a single. Conviction, while corrupt public official openly display their ill gotten wealth without any fear of any kind.

Although the Freedom of Information Act has been enacted, citzen access to information about the assests declared by public officials have been heavilly restricted and at best a citzens power stops at making complaints to the Code of Conduct Bureau as private indivuals cannot prosecute cases at the tribunal, this is in contradiction with the well established principle of nemo judex in causa, the bureau investigates and also prosecutes while the same code of conduct tribunal abjudicates on the case investigated by the same bureau. Unlike the regular courts that is largely controlled by the national judicial council the CCB and CCT is directly under the presidency and it well known that he who pays the piper dictates the tune. It is therefore not surprising that most cases tried by the tribunal end with political settlements rather than conviction.
In conclusion, the writer submits, that the Code of Conduct Tribunal as is presently constituted is ill placed to discharge it's statutory functions. Established by the past miltary regime, the CCB and CCT still has relics of of the miltary regime as  it carries out adminstrative, prosecutorial and abjudicatoty powers , very importantly also,  the interdependence between the CCB & CCT works to deny the tribunal of its Supposed impartial outlook. To resolve this contradictions,  therefore, the tribunal should be dissolved via constitutional amendment and the Code of Conduct Bureau should be  empowered  to investigate and prosecute cases relating to the code of conduct of public officers before either the High Court.

No comments:

Post a Comment